E-commerce subscription churn cost: replenishment vs curation models
Chewy and Stitch Fix, two listed subscription commerce companies, do not publish a churn rate. What they do publish shows how much rides on keeping subscribers: Chewy's Autoship customers accounted for 84.6% of its net sales in the 13 weeks to 2 August 2026, and it reported net sales of $602 per active customer. Each customer who stops ordering takes their share of that with them.
What subscription commerce companies report
| Company | Metric | Value | Period |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chewy | Autoship customer sales as a share of net sales | 84.6% | 13 weeks to 2 Aug 2026 |
| Chewy | Active customers | 21.705M | 2 Aug 2026 |
| Chewy | Net sales per active customer | $602 | 2 Aug 2026 |
| Stitch Fix | Active clients | 2.277M | 1 Aug 2026 |
| Stitch Fix | Net revenue per active client | $592 | 1 Aug 2026 |
These are retention proxies, not churn rates. Stitch Fix counts a client as active if they checked out a Fix or were shipped an item in the preceding 52 weeks, so a client who stops ordering keeps counting for up to a year; Chewy's Autoship share measures how much revenue comes from customers on repeat delivery, not how many leave. Stitch Fix's active clients were lower at 1 August 2026 than a year earlier, while its revenue per active client rose.
Replenishment vs curation
Replenishment subscriptions deliver something the customer would buy anyway: pet food, razor blades, coffee, vitamins. The subscription removes a shopping trip and often comes with a discount, and cancellations tend to follow a cadence problem (too much product piling up, or running out) or a better price elsewhere. Chewy's Autoship is this model.
Curation subscriptions sell discovery: clothing picked by a stylist, a box of new products each month. The value is novelty, so cancellations follow when the selection stops surprising the customer or misses their taste. Stitch Fix is this model.
Dollar Shave Club
Dollar Shave Club never published a churn rate either. Unilever announced its sale to Nexus Capital Management, a US private equity firm, on 26 October 2023, keeping a 35% minority shareholding, with financial terms undisclosed. The lesson for an operator is the one in the table above: outsiders see active customers and revenue, not churn, so the churn maths has to be your own.
Three-layer cost for subscription boxes
Layer one (recurring contribution lost): measure a churned subscriber in gross-margin contribution, not revenue, because every box carries product, packing and shipping cost. Monthly price x gross margin is the monthly contribution that leaves.
Layer two (wasted acquisition cost): divide acquisition cost by monthly contribution to get payback in months. A subscriber who leaves before that month never repaid what it cost to sign them.
Layer three (forfeited expansion): usually small, showing up as add-on products, extra pets or people, and second addresses that a churned subscriber never adds.
Run your own price, margin, churn and acquisition cost through the churn cost calculator.
Retention levers for subscription boxes
- Cadence control. Let subscribers change delivery frequency, skip a delivery or pause, so a cadence problem does not become a cancellation.
- A cancellation flow with alternatives. Offer skip, swap and pause before cancel, and record which one each saved subscriber took.
- Failed-payment recovery. Expired and declined cards end subscriptions nobody chose to cancel. See involuntary churn.
- Cohort tracking. Measure the share of each month's sign-ups still ordering after 1, 3, 6 and 12 months.
US cancellation rules also matter: the FTC's 2024 click-to-cancel rule was vacated before it took effect, and state automatic-renewal laws still apply. The B2C subscription churn cost page has the current position.
Frequently asked questions
Related reading on ChurnCost
- E-commerce churn calculator, the broader e-commerce retention picture.
- B2C subscription churn cost, with SiriusXM and Peloton churn from their filings.
- Mobile app subscription churn cost, with Apple and Google subscription fees.
- Gym and fitness subscription churn cost, with what Peloton and Planet Fitness disclose.
- Involuntary churn, the payment-failure recovery framework.
- Retention playbook, the diagnostic framework.
Figures checked 14 November 2026 against Chewy's Q2 fiscal 2026 and Stitch Fix's Q4 fiscal 2026 earnings releases (SEC) and Unilever's 26 October 2023 press release.